When representing business sellers it is important to
recognize that this is usually their first and only experience in selling their
business. No matter how smart they are, there is no replacement for experience
in this complex process. Also, any
mistakes made during this process are usually very expensive, time consuming or
both. Finally, it is usually an
emotional roller coaster for the owner - Am I doing the right thing? is this
the right time? What is going to happen
to my employees and my customers? Is this the right buyer? Are these the best
price and terms I can get?
Because this process is so foreign and the emotions run so
high, a seemingly simple action on the part of the buyer, if not anticipated
and not prepared for, could disrupt or even blow up a mutually beneficial
transaction. If our client gets surprised by a deal event and that event does some damage, I take that on as my
responsibility. It takes only one deal to blow up to turn you into a serial
client preparer.
To improve our odds of deal completion and success we make
sure our clients are prepared for each stage of the deal, from the number one question - why are you
selling, to the conference calls,
corporate visits, frequently asked questions, letters of intent, buyer
negotiations tactics, post closing adjustments, etc. The way we do this is
every time we encounter something during a deal that our client should be
prepared for or could cause an issue if not properly handled, we write a short
article about it.
Then when we are coming up on a particular deal element or
deal stage, we send our client the article to read and then we discuss it with
them. This is, very importantly, not reacting to the emotions during the heat
of battle, but more like a run through practice prior to the big game. The team usually does better if they are
prepared for the fake punt rather than experiencing it with the score tied with
two minutes to go in the fourth quarter. So our dry run is done with no
pressure, prior to the event, and most importantly, with emotions in check.
Just when I think that I have seen all the "gotchas"
there are after fifteen years of grinding out deals, and that my article
library was complete, we had a new issue come up which caused several hours of
nervousness within the seller's team and the buyer's team.
We had all of the major deal terms worked out and detailed
in a very comprehensive Letter of Intent and were requesting that the partner
sellers countersign it to agree to go into quiet period and buyer due
diligence.
One of the partners was completely on board but the other
could not get his head around not retaining all of his owner perks - company
lease on a luxury vehicle, fully paid cell phone, home internet service and a
few others. For his future employment with the new company those would be
handled at a much less generous and customary employee expense treatment.
I was a little taken aback by this and my first thought was,
"is this guy going to blow up a deal for what amounts to less than one
half of 1% of deal value? Then I remembered why we have written all of these
articles. In the heat of battle, this guy was dealing with all of the emotions
of turning his clients, employees, and even a good part of his identity for the
past decade, over to a new caretaker. I really could not blame him for not
displaying some good old fashioned emotionally detached logical thinking. What
I had to do was to step back and see if I could provide some solid logic so
that he would get beyond this potential deal
breaker(while I was talking myself off the ledge as well).
It went something like this. Bill, remember in the
memorandum we made all of those adjustments to remove owner perks from your
financials and applied those adjustments to increase your EBITDA. Well those
were very powerful because the buyer looked at those expenses as being
eliminated after he owned the company and when he applied his 5X multiple your
adjusted EBITDA, it resulted in an
increase in your sales price of 5 times your eliminated expenses. Now if you
want the buyer to incur those expenses once he owns the company, will you be happy with an adjusted purchase price
reduced by 5 X those expenses? Believe
me, you are much better off with multiplying the perks by 5 and receiving that bump in transaction
value.
It was beautiful, logical, insightful, but at the end of the
day, his partner convinced him to take the deal.
Well, at least I have another article, a little more wisdom,
a couple of more gray hairs, and can prevent this from happening on the next
deal.
Dave Kauppi is a Merger and Acquisition Advisor and President of MidMarket Capital, providing business broker and investment banking services to owners in the sale of lower middle market companies. For more information about exit planning and selling a business, click to subscribe to our free newsletter The Exit Strategist
No comments:
Post a Comment